No-Fault and At-Fault Systems in an Edmonton Car Accident

If you’re driving in Edmonton and have a car accident, knowing the rules can help you a lot. Here, we deal with accidents using a mix of No-Fault and At-Fault rules.  “At-Fault” means the driver who caused the accident pays for the damage. “No-Fault” means your insurance company pays for your damages, no matter who caused the crash.  Knowing how this works is important because it affects your insurance and what happens after an accident.  Let us delve into the intricacies of both the At-Fault and No-Fault Systems, compare their impacts, and provide you with the knowledge you need to navigate the aftermath of an Edmonton car accident with confidence.  
edmonton car accident

What is the At-Fault System?

Imagine you’re driving, and there’s a crash. If the other driver caused it, under the At-Fault system, they pay for the damage. We figure out who’s to blame by looking at the accident details.  Was someone speeding? Did a driver ignore a red light? These facts help decide who’s at fault.   Let’s look at what happens to the driver who’s at fault:  
Consequence Description
Insurance Premium Goes up, because they’re now a higher risk.
Legal Liability They could get sued for other people’s car repairs and medical bills.
Driving Record Gets points for the accident, which can lead to more costs and hassles.

What is the No-Fault System?

When a crash happens, the No-Fault system means your insurance company pays for your car repairs and medical bills, regardless of who caused the accident. You don’t have to wait for the insurance companies to battle over who’s to blame; you just file a claim with your insurer, and they cover your costs up to your policy’s limits.   Below is a quick comparison of how No-Fault differs from At-Fault regarding handling claims and compensation:  
Aspect No-Fault System At-Fault System
Claims Process You file with your insurer, and they pay out quickly. You can file a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer, which can take time.
Determining Fault Not necessary for your claim. Essential to determine who pays.
Compensation Usually limited to policy limits; less chance of suing for more. Potential for suing for additional damages.
  And what about the pros and cons of the No-Fault system? Let’s take a look:  
Advantages Disadvantages
Quick Payment Limits on suing
Less hassle Will not cover all costs
No need to prove fault Premiums can rise if abused
  The No-Fault system aims to make things smoother and quicker for everyone involved. It trades off the chance to get more money through lawsuits for a speedy and sure payment process.

General Comparison Between No-Fault and At-Fault Systems

Here’s a detailed comparison of aspects that are particularly relevant to victims in the event of an accident:    
Key Aspect No-Fault System Details At-Fault System Details
Vehicle Repairs – Repairs are usually covered quickly.  – No need to wait for fault determination. – Repairs covered by at-fault party’s insurance.  – Potential delays if liability is disputed.
Income Loss – Often provides for lost wages due to accident-related injuries.  – Benefits can have limits based on policy. – Recovery of lost income can be claimed from at-fault party.   – Would result in more significant compensation if proven.
Pain and Suffering – Not typically covered; focuses on economic losses. – Claimable from the at-fault party, including emotional distress.
Policy Deductibles – Deductibles can apply regardless of who is at fault.  – Can affect out-of-pocket expenses. – Deductible is often recovered if you are not at fault.   – The at-fault party’s insurance can reimburse your deductible.
Legal Proceedings – Legal proceedings are rare due to restricted right to sue. – More common, especially for serious injuries or disputes over fault.
  When will one system be more beneficial than the other? Below are a couple of scenarios:  
  • No-Fault is better if you want a faster payout for your damages without the hassle of legal disputes, or if the fault is hard to prove.
  • At-Fault works in your favour when you’re not responsible for the accident and the other driver has enough insurance to cover all the damages that exceed your policy.

Impact on Edmonton Drivers

Let’s talk about what you need to do and some smart moves to make if you ever get into a bump on the road.

What You Need to Have:

  • You’ve got to carry insurance that covers the other guy’s car and any injuries if the crash is your fault.
  • You also need insurance that’ll pay for your injuries, no matter who caused the accident.
  • If you’re in a big crash, you must let your insurance know within a month and also tell the police.

Smart Tips for Dealing with Accidents:

If You’re Under No-Fault If You’re Under At-Fault
Snap some pics at the scene and jot down what happened. This helps get your claim sorted fast. Prove Your Point: Round up any evidence to show it wasn’t your fault.
Ensure you understand what your insurance covers and what you must pay for. Learn how you can get money from the other driver’s insurance if they caused the crash.
Go see a doctor immediately because your insurer has your back for medical bills. Watch what you say. Anything you mention could be used to figure out who’s at fault.
Tell your insurer about the crash as soon as possible to kick off the claim process. Be prepared to discuss your claim with the other driver’s insurance to get what you deserve.
Write down all your costs from the crash; your insurer can cover them. If you’re hurt badly, or there’s a fight over who’s to blame, a lawyer would be your next move.

edmonton car accident

Secure Your Rights Today

For Edmonton car accidents, understanding the differences between No-Fault and At-Fault systems is important, especially if you’re involved in a car or motor vehicle incident that results in an injury.  If injured and uncertain about the implications for your family, reach out to us at Sidhu Personal Injury Lawyers Edmonton for professional service immediately. For specific guidance on your situation, contact a legal advisor by phone to discuss the details of your case.

Frequently Asked Questions


Deductible Responsibility

Potential for Deductible Recovery

You’re not at fault

You pay the deductible to your insurer.

You can recover the deductible if the at-fault party is insured and identifiable.

The at-fault driver is uninsured or unidentified

You still pay the deductible.

Recovery is unlikely; your insurer can cover you depending on your policy.

Partial fault on both sides

You pay the deductible.

Partial recovery can be possible depending on the degree of fault.

The at-fault driver is fully insured and at fault

You pay the deductible initially.

Your insurer can recover the deductible from the at-fault driver’s insurer through subrogation.

In Edmonton, as in the rest of Alberta, the Limitations Act, 2002 suggests you generally have 2 years from the date of the car accident to commence a lawsuit against the at-fault party. This is known as the limitation period. 


Yet, there are exceptions to this rule, and specific circumstances can extend or shorten this time frame. It’s important to consult with a lawyer to understand how these limitation periods apply to your specific situation

In Canada, lawyer fees can vary greatly depending on the complexity of the case and the billing structure the lawyer offers. Generally, hourly rates for lawyers in private practice range from $75 to $750 CAD. The cost will be influenced by the lawyer’s experience, with more seasoned lawyers charging at the higher end of the spectrum. 


Clients can also opt for a flat rate for certain legal services, which provides a clear upfront cost. Some lawyers could offer capped rates, where a maximum billing amount is set, or sliding fees based on the client’s income.

You should consider seeing a lawyer as soon as possible after a car accident, especially if there are injuries or significant damage. A lawyer can help you navigate the legal system, deal with insurance companies, and ensure that all necessary timelines and requirements are met. 

In Alberta, there are specific deadlines for taking legal action, and failing to meet these can affect your ability to claim. Prompt legal advice can protect your rights and interests after an accident​.

Share this:

We’re not around right now. But you can send us an email and we’ll get back to you, asap.